No, you absolutely should not tow a car with the emergency brake on. Doing so will cause significant damage to your vehicle and can create extremely dangerous towing situations. This guide will explore the risks, proper towing methods, and essential precautions to ensure safe vehicle transportation.
Image Source: i.imgur.com
The Perils of Emergency Brake Towing
Attempting to tow a car with the emergency brake engaged is a recipe for disaster. The emergency brake, also known as the parking brake, is designed to lock the rear wheels (or sometimes all four, depending on the vehicle) to prevent movement. When you try to pull a vehicle with this system activated, you are essentially dragging a locked set of wheels across the ground. This creates immense friction and stress on multiple components.
What Happens When You Tow with the Emergency Brake On?
When the emergency brake is engaged, it exerts a significant clamping force on the brake drums or rotors, preventing rotation. If you attempt towing a car in this state, the towing vehicle is forced to overcome this resistance. This results in:
- Tire Damage: The tires will be subjected to extreme friction, leading to rapid wear, flat spots, and potentially even blowouts. The rubber can overheat and melt.
- Brake System Damage: The brake pads, rotors, calipers, and associated hardware will experience severe wear and tear. Overheating can warp rotors, damage pads, and compromise the entire braking system.
- Drivetrain Strain: The differential, driveshaft, and axles are under immense stress as they are forced to turn against a locked wheel assembly. This can lead to premature wear and costly repairs.
- Transmission Damage: In rear-wheel-drive vehicles, if the rear wheels are locked, the transmission can be severely damaged as it tries to rotate the driveshaft while the rear axle is immobilized. This is a critical point in damage towing.
- Frame and Suspension Stress: The entire frame and suspension system of the towed vehicle will be subjected to abnormal forces as it’s dragged. This can lead to bent components, misaligned wheels, and compromised structural integrity.
- Towing Vehicle Strain: Your towing vehicle will also suffer from the increased resistance. Its brakes, engine, and drivetrain will be worked harder than intended, increasing wear and the risk of overheating or mechanical failure.
Visualizing the Force: A Simple Analogy
Imagine trying to push a heavy filing cabinet across a room with one of its drawers firmly jammed shut. It’s incredibly difficult, requires much more effort, and you risk damaging the drawer, the cabinet, or both. Emergency brake towing is a more extreme version of this scenario.
The Severity of Towing Damage
The towing damage incurred can be extensive and expensive. What might seem like a simple towing job can quickly turn into a costly repair bill. The components that bear the brunt of the force include:
- Brake Drums/Rotors
- Brake Pads/Shoes
- Brake Calipers
- Wheel Cylinders
- Parking Brake Cables
- Tires
- Axles
- Differential
- Transmission
- Driveshaft
- Suspension Components
- Frame
Proper Towing Methods: The Safe Alternatives
When it comes to safely transporting a vehicle, several approved towing methods are available. Each method is designed to isolate the driven wheels from the ground or to lift the vehicle entirely, preventing any strain on the towed car’s powertrain and braking systems.
Flat Towing (Dolly Towing)
This is a common and safe method where the front wheels of the towed vehicle are placed on a tow dolly, and the rear wheels remain on the ground.
- How it Works: The dolly is essentially a small trailer with wheels that attaches to the hitch of the towing vehicle. The front wheels of the towed car are secured onto the dolly, lifting them off the ground.
- When to Use: This method is ideal for front-wheel-drive vehicles. The rear wheels are still rolling, but this is acceptable as they are not connected to the engine and are generally more robust to rolling freely.
- Towing Safety: Crucially, the emergency brake engaged on the towed vehicle must be released, and the transmission must be in neutral.
- Towing Precautions: Ensure the dolly is rated for the weight of your vehicle and that the towed car is securely attached to the dolly.
Car Carrier (Full Tow Truck Bed)
This is arguably the safest method, as the entire towed vehicle is lifted onto the bed of a specialized car carrier tow truck.
- How it Works: The tow truck has a platform that hydraulically lowers, allowing the towed vehicle to be driven or winched onto it. Once secured, all four wheels are off the ground.
- When to Use: This method is suitable for all types of vehicles, including front-wheel drive, rear-wheel drive, all-wheel drive, and vehicles with automatic transmissions or complex braking systems. It eliminates all towing risks.
- Towing Safety: No special action is needed regarding the emergency brake on the towed vehicle, as its wheels will not be turning.
- Towing Precautions: Ensure the vehicle is properly chocked and strapped to the carrier to prevent movement during transit.
Tow Dollies (All Four Wheels Off the Ground)
Some specialized tow dollies are designed to lift all four wheels of the towed vehicle off the ground.
- How it Works: This involves a more complex setup where the entire vehicle is supported by the dolly.
- When to Use: This is a versatile option that works for most vehicle types.
- Towing Safety: Again, the emergency brake engaged must be released, and the transmission should be in neutral or the appropriate setting for towing (refer to the vehicle’s owner manual).
- Towing Precautions: Proper securing of the vehicle to the dolly is paramount.
Towing with a Tow Bar
This method involves attaching a tow bar directly to the frame of the towed vehicle and connecting it to the hitch of the towing vehicle.
- How it Works: The towed car’s front wheels are typically on the ground, and the steering wheel needs to be unlocked and often secured with a steering wheel lock device to follow the towing vehicle.
- When to Use: This method is primarily used for vehicles that are designed for flat towing (often those with manual transmissions or specific “dinghy towing” capabilities).
- Towing Safety: It is absolutely critical to consult the towed vehicle’s owner manual to determine if it is suitable for flat towing. The emergency brake engaged must be released, and the transmission must be in neutral. Many modern vehicles with electronic parking brakes require specific procedures to disengage them, and some cannot be flat-towed at all due to potential towing damage.
- Towing Precautions: A supplemental braking system for the towed vehicle is highly recommended and often legally required. This system applies the towed vehicle’s brakes when the towing vehicle brakes.
Deciphering the Emergency Brake System
The emergency brake, or parking brake, is a secondary braking system independent of the main hydraulic brake system. It’s designed to hold the vehicle stationary, especially when parked on inclines.
How the Emergency Brake Works
- Mechanical Linkage: Most commonly, the emergency brake operates via a mechanical cable system that directly applies pressure to the brake shoes or pads at the rear wheels (or sometimes all wheels).
- Electronic Parking Brakes (EPB): Modern vehicles are increasingly equipped with electronic parking brakes. These use an electric motor to engage the braking mechanism. While convenient, they can present unique challenges when towing.
Why Releasing is Crucial
When the emergency brake engaged status is present during towing, it’s like trying to drag a strongly anchored object. The mechanical or electrical force holding the wheels locked is immense. The kinetic energy of the towing vehicle is trying to force the stationary wheels to rotate, leading to the detrimental effects mentioned earlier. Releasing the emergency brake is the most basic yet critical step in towing safety.
Risks Associated with Emergency Brake Towing
Beyond the immediate damage towing can cause, there are significant safety risks to consider.
Loss of Control
A vehicle with its emergency brake partially engaged can behave unpredictably. The uneven resistance can cause the towed vehicle to sway or pull erratically, potentially leading to a loss of control for both vehicles.
Tire Blowouts
The intense heat generated by friction can cause tires to overheat and fail catastrophically. A tire blowout while towing a car can easily cause a jackknife situation or a complete loss of control.
Brake System Failure
Overheated brakes can fail entirely. If the towed vehicle’s brakes seize or disintegrate due to the strain, it can be a major safety hazard.
Mechanical Breakdowns
The excessive stress can cause drivetrain components to break, leaving both vehicles stranded and potentially causing accidents.
Essential Towing Precautions
To ensure towing safety and prevent costly towing damage, adhere to these crucial precautions:
Always Consult the Owner’s Manual
This is non-negotiable. The owner’s manual for the vehicle being towed will provide specific instructions on whether it can be towed, and if so, the recommended towing methods and any special procedures. It will clarify how to disengage the parking brake, especially for electronic systems.
Securely Release the Parking Brake
Before attempting any towing a car, physically verify that the emergency brake is fully disengaged. For vehicles with traditional hand levers or foot pedals, pull them up or push them down completely. For electronic parking brakes (EPBs), follow the procedure outlined in the owner’s manual, which usually involves starting the car, engaging the regular brakes, and then using a button or switch to release the EPB. Some EPBs automatically re-engage after a certain time or if the vehicle’s battery dies, so vigilance is key.
Neutral Gear is Essential
When towing a car, the transmission must be in neutral. This allows the wheels to spin freely without putting stress on the transmission components. For automatic transmissions, ensure it’s in the “N” (Neutral) position. For manual transmissions, shift into neutral.
Proper Connection and Securing
Ensure all towing equipment, whether a dolly, car carrier, or tow bar, is properly rated for the weight of the towed vehicle and is securely attached to both vehicles. Use appropriate safety chains or cables.
Check Tires
Inspect the tires of the towed vehicle for proper inflation and condition. Worn or underinflated tires are more susceptible to damage.
Monitor Gauges and Mirrors
While towing a car, frequently check your mirrors to monitor the towed vehicle. Listen for unusual noises and feel for any vibrations that might indicate a problem.
Drive Cautiously
Adjust your driving style to accommodate the towed vehicle. Accelerate and brake gradually, and allow for much longer stopping distances. Avoid sudden maneuvers.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q1: Can I tow my car with an automatic transmission if the emergency brake is released?
A1: Generally, it is not recommended to tow a car with an automatic transmission with its drive wheels on the ground, even with the emergency brake released. Many automatic transmissions can be damaged by being towed this way because internal components continue to rotate without proper lubrication. Consult your owner’s manual. For automatic transmissions, a car carrier or a tow dolly that lifts all four wheels is the safest option.
Q2: What about vehicles with all-wheel drive (AWD) or four-wheel drive (4WD)?
A2: Towing AWD or 4WD vehicles with their wheels on the ground is almost always a bad idea, regardless of the emergency brake status. This is because the system is designed to drive all four wheels simultaneously. Forcing them to roll at different speeds can severely damage the transfer case and differentials. A car carrier is the only safe method for most AWD/4WD vehicles. Some manufacturers offer specific neutral tow modes for their 4WD vehicles, but this is rare and must be explicitly stated in the owner’s manual.
Q3: My car has an electronic parking brake. How do I disengage it for towing?
A3: The procedure for disengaging an electronic parking brake (EPB) varies by manufacturer and model. Typically, you will need to start the engine, press and hold the brake pedal, and then activate the EPB release button or switch. Crucially, you must refer to your vehicle’s owner’s manual for the exact procedure. Some EPBs might re-engage automatically if the battery is disconnected or after a period of time, so re-checking is important.
Q4: What are the legal implications of towing with the emergency brake on?
A4: While specific laws vary by region, operating a vehicle in a manner that causes excessive damage or creates a hazard is generally illegal. Towing risks associated with an engaged emergency brake could lead to citations for unsafe vehicle operation, damage to public roadways, and liability for any accidents caused.
Q5: How can I check if the emergency brake is fully released?
A5: For manual systems, ensure the lever is in its lowest position or the pedal is fully up. For electronic systems, the dashboard indicator light for the parking brake should be off after you have followed the release procedure in the owner’s manual. Listen for any sounds of the brake mechanism still being engaged.
Q6: Is it safe to tow a car with a weak or malfunctioning emergency brake?
A6: Even a partially engaged or weak emergency brake can cause significant towing damage and create towing risks. If you suspect any issue with the parking brake system, it’s best to have it inspected and repaired before attempting to tow the vehicle. Using a car carrier eliminates this concern entirely.
By understanding the critical importance of releasing the emergency brake and employing the correct towing methods, you can ensure the safety of yourself, others, and the vehicles involved in the towing process. Prioritizing towing safety always means avoiding emergency brake towing at all costs.